Both of these lean on tequila and lime, but they land in different places on the palate. Deciding between them mostly comes down to how much heat your crowd wants and what season you're serving in.
Flavor profile
| NO. 03 Spicy Paloma | NO. 07 Watermelon Margarita | |
|---|---|---|
| Base flavors | Grapefruit, hibiscus, lime, jalapeño | Watermelon, lime, basil, pink pepper |
| Feel | Bitter, spicy, bracing | Sweet, herbal, refreshing |
| Best paired spirit | Tequila | Tequila |
Who tends to prefer which
The Spicy Paloma appeals to guests who already gravitate toward a Paloma or a Margarita with extra spice. It has real jalapeño heat, not a token amount, so it's a better fit for a crowd that likes bold, bitter drinks.
The Watermelon Margarita is the more universally approachable of the two. The basil and pink pepper add complexity without pushing the drink into spicy or bitter territory, which makes it a safer default for a large, mixed guest list.
Seasonal fit
Watermelon Margarita reads as a summer drink and fits pool parties, backyard events, and daytime weddings. Spicy Paloma works year-round but leans slightly better into fall and winter gatherings where a little heat feels seasonal rather than out of place.
If you're only picking one
For a general crowd where you're not sure of the spice tolerance, go with the Watermelon Margarita. For a crowd that already orders spicy drinks at a bar, go with the Spicy Paloma.
Colorway NO. 07 (Watermelon Margarita)
Watermelon, lime, basil, and pink pepper. Add tequila for a Margarita, or keep it alcohol-free for a summer cooler.
View product →